Caring for Illness - Statewide - Commercial Managed Care

Plan Appropriate
Treatment for URI
Appropriate
Testing for
Pharyngitis
Use of Appropriate
Medications for People
With Asthma (Ages 5-17)
ADHD Initiation ADHD Continuation
Aetna 85  82  96  45 Significantly better than Statewide Average 60 Significantly better than Statewide Average
BSNENY 89 Significantly better than Statewide Average 80 Significantly worse than Statewide Average 97  49 Significantly better than Statewide Average 50
CDPHP 87 Significantly better than Statewide Average 77 Significantly worse than Statewide Average 96  42  44
CIGNA 90 Significantly better than Statewide Average 83  92  47  --
Community Blue 84  60 Significantly worse than Statewide Average 93 Significantly worse than Statewide Average 40  45
Empire 81 Significantly worse than Statewide Average 88 Significantly better than Statewide Average 96  30 Significantly worse than Statewide Average 34
Excellus BlueCross BlueShield 89 Significantly better than Statewide Average 87 Significantly better than Statewide Average 95  31 Significantly worse than Statewide Average 29 Significantly worse than Statewide Average
GHI HMO 83  81  97  40  --
HIP 85  81 Significantly worse than Statewide Average 93 Significantly worse than Statewide Average 44 Significantly better than Statewide Average 41
Health Net of New York, Inc. 87 Significantly better than Statewide Average 85 Significantly better than Statewide Average 95  34  32
Independent Health 83 Significantly worse than Statewide Average 88 Significantly better than Statewide Average 99 Significantly better than Statewide Average 32  32
MVP 86 Significantly better than Statewide Average 79 Significantly worse than Statewide Average 96  44 Significantly better than Statewide Average 48
Oxford 87 Significantly better than Statewide Average 86 Significantly better than Statewide Average 96  40  47
Preferred Care 90 Significantly better than Statewide Average 88 Significantly better than Statewide Average 96  33  37
Univera HealthCare 88 Significantly better than Statewide Average 68 Significantly worse than Statewide Average 94  37  53
Statewide Average 85 83 95 37 40
National Average 84 75 * 34 39
Significantly better than Statewide Average Significantly better than the statewide average.
Significantly worse than Statewide Average Significantly worse than the statewide average.
-- Sample size too small to report.
* No national average available.

Note Plans without symbols are consistent with the statewide average.

National average is based on 2007 data from the National Committee for Quality Assurance (NCQA).