Managing Acute Illnesses - Statewide - Commercial Managed Care

Plan Colorectal
Cancer
Screening
Use of Imaging
Studies for Low
Back Pain
Avoidance of
Antibiotic Therapy
in Adults with
Acute Bronchitis
Advising
Smokers to
Quit
Discussing
Smoking Cessation
Medications
Discussing
Smoking Cessation
Strategies
Flu Shot
For Adults
Aetna 54 Significantly worse    than Statewide Average 77  28 Significantly better than Statewide Average 82  55  51  45
BSNENY 65  76  17 Significantly worse than Statewide Average 82  62  58  47
CDPHP 66  73 Significantly worse than Statewide Average 16 Significantly worse than Statewide Average 82  61  54  52
CIGNA 60  75 Significantly worse than Statewide Average 33 Significantly better than Statewide Average 70  55  43  43
Community Blue 59  82 Significantly better than Statewide Average 17 Significantly worse than Statewide Average 83  57  53  48
Empire 56 Significantly worse than Statewide Average 75 Significantly worse than Statewide Average 23  74  51  52  41 Significantly worse than Statewide Average
Excellus BlueCross BlueShield 66 Significantly better    than Statewide Average 84 Significantly better than Statewide Average 19 Significantly worse than Statewide Average 88 Significantly better than Statewide Average 70 Significantly better than Statewide Average 57  61 Significantly better than Statewide Average
GHI HMO 52 Significantly worse than Statewide Average 78  19 Significantly worse than Statewide Average 83  55  50  42 Significantly worse than Statewide Average
HIP 57 Significantly worse    than Statewide Average 83 Significantly better than Statewide Average 26 Significantly better than Statewide Average 68 Significantly worse than Statewide Average 41 Significantly worse than Statewide Average 39 Significantly worse than Statewide Average 37 Significantly worse than Statewide Average
Health Net of New York, Inc. 67 Significantly better than Statewide Average 77  30 Significantly better than Statewide Average 81  51  41  55 Significantly better than Statewide Average
Independent Health 66 Significantly better    than Statewide Average 83 Significantly better than Statewide Average 17 Significantly worse than Statewide Average 75  49  44  51
MVP 63  69 Significantly worse than Statewide Average 22 Significantly worse than Statewide Average 85  64 Significantly better than Statewide Average 59 Significantly better than Statewide Average 48
Oxford 66  75 Significantly worse than Statewide Average 34 Significantly better than Statewide Average 83  55  56  48
Preferred Care 60  84 Significantly better than Statewide Average 19 Significantly worse than Statewide Average 80  59  51  57 Significantly better than Statewide Average
Univera HealthCare 66  76  19 Significantly worse than Statewide Average 85  47 Significantly worse than Statewide Average 46  51
Statewide Average 61 78 24 80 56 50 49
National Average 56 75 25 76 51 48 49
Significantly better than Statewide Average Significantly better than the statewide average.
Significantly worse than Statewide Average Significantly worse than the statewide average.

Note Plans without symbols are consistent with the statewide average.

National average is based on 2007 data from the National Committee for Quality Assurance (NCQA).