NY Medicaid Electronic Visit Verification (EVV) Program

  • FAQs also available in Portable Document Format (PDF)

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Version 1.4
Updated March 9, 2021


Background

The following FAQs have been asked through the EVVHelp@health.ny.gov inbox by various stakeholders. These FAQs will help inform common inquires and assist providers and fiscal intermediaries in successful EVV implementation in New York State.


EVV FAQs

Q: What is Electronic Visit Verification?

A: Electronic Visit Verification, or EVV, is an electronic system that verifies when a provider visit occurs and captures the date and time of the visit, the location of the visit, the person who received the services, the person who provided the services, and the services provided. In most cases, a signature or voice verification from the individual receiving the services can also be captured.

Q: Why is New York State implementing an EVV system?

A: New York Medicaid is required by federal law to implement an EVV system for certain home- and community-based services. The law, referred to as the 21st Century Cures Act, can be found in Public Law 114-255, Section 12006(a)(4)(B).

Q: What are the goals of EVV?

A: For beneficiaries and families, EVV ensures timely service delivery, including real-time service gap reporting and monitoring. For providers and fiscal intermediaries, EVV reduces the administrative burden associated with paper timesheet processing and generates cost savings from the prevention of fraud, waste, and abuse.

EVV may help ensure adequate care and timely service delivery for beneficiaries and families and may help prevent Medicaid fraud, waste, and abuse. EVV may also reduce administrative overhead for providers and fiscal intermediaries leading to additional cost savings.

Q: What is the selected Model for implementing EVV in New York State?

A: New York selected the Choice Model for the following reasons: (1) it best ensures that consumers will have EVV options from which to consider when selecting a provider; (2) it gives providers of service the flexibility to select an option that best meets their business needs and the needs of the consumers they serve; and (3) it recognizes that many providers serving New York´s Medicaid consumers have already implemented EVV systems that meet the requirements of the Cures Act, preserving the investment that has already been made, avoiding duplicative costs, and eliminating disruption to consumers and caregivers.

To implement the Choice Model, the New York State Department of Health (NYSDOH) will require that providers of Medicaid-funded personal care services (PCS) select and put into production use EVV systems that meet the requirements of the 21st Century Cures Act by January 1, 2021. Providers of Medicaid-funded Home Health Care Services (HHCS) will be required to select and implement such systems by January 1, 2023. In addition, providers will be required to submit EVV data to NYSDOH, which will be aggregated for reporting and audit purposes.

Q: What is the Choice Model?

A: Under the Choice Model, providers and fiscal intermediaries are able to implement an EVV system that best meets the needs of the recipients they serve and that they determine is best suited to meet their individual administrative needs. Such systems must meet the requirements of the 21st Century Cures Act and must be able to submit data to New York State, which will be aggregated for reporting and audit purposes.

As recommended by Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) guidance, NYSDOH will provide statewide EVV data aggregation through New York´s Medicaid Management Information System (MMIS). In keeping with the Cures Act requirement to implement EVV in a way that is "minimally burdensome," and in response to concerns from stakeholders regarding privacy and self-direction, during its initial implementation, only the minimum set of EVV data elements necessary to meet the obligations under the Cures Act will be aggregated. To illustrate, while the Choice Model allows providers and fiscal intermediaries to utilize multiple methods of collecting EVV data (for example, home phone number, fob, or GPS-enabled mobile applications), New York will launch data aggregation with a limited set of data needed to meet the requirements of the Cures Act. Once the initial implementation period is complete, NYSDOH will assess the EVV program and may, as a result, modify data aggregation to support initiatives to improve quality and access to services.

Q: What happens if a State Medicaid Program did not implement the EVV requirement?

A: If EVV was not implemented, federal law requires the Center for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) to reduce the Federal Medical Assistance Percentage (FMAP) rate or amount of federal payments given to a State for personal care and home health care services. FMAP reductions for PCS and HHCS are reflected in the chart below.

Year PCS HHCS
2021 0.25%  
2022 0.50%  
2023 0.75% 0.25%
2024 1.00% 0.25%
2025 1.00% 0.50%
2026 1.00% 0.75%
2027 & Thereafter 1.00% 1.00%

Reduction percentages do not compound each year.

Q: When was EVV required to be implemented by?

A: States required EVV for all Medicaid-funded Personal Care Services (PCS) to begin by January 1, 2020. States will require EVV for all Home Health Care Services (HHCS) to begin by January 1, 2023.

Per Section 12006(a)(4)(B) of the 21st Century Cures Act, states can apply for a one-year extension, if a state has encountered unavoidable system delays in implementing an EVV system and can show it has made a "good faith effort" (GFE) to comply. If a "good faith effort" exemption is granted, CMS will not reduce the federal medical assistance percentage (FMAP) for calendar quarters in 2020 (for PCS) or for calendar quarters in 2023 (for HHCS).

On December 5, 2019, New York State Received the Good Faith Effort Exemption from Federal Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS), delaying EVV implementation for PCS until January 1, 2021.

Q: How will NYSDOH collect input from the stakeholders?

A: NYSDOH has carefully considered feedback from Medicaid beneficiaries, family caregivers, providers, advocates, and other stakeholders on the State’s implementation of EVV. We have received input during EVV Listening Sessions as well as responses to the EVV Readiness Survey and conducted a Request for Information (RFI) for EVV solutions. NYSDOH has also established an email address dedicated to responding to questions and comments related to EVV.

New York State will continue to engage with stakeholders to ensure a smooth and well-informed implementation, including any required training for those impacted by EVV. We will monitor the implementation and work to address issues that may arise.

Upcoming opportunities for stakeholder engagement will be posted to the NYS EVV website. NYSDOH will also notify the public via the EVV Listserv.

To sign up for the EVV Listserv, email listserv@listserv.health.state.ny.us with the following in the body of your email: SUBSCRIBE EVV-L YourFirstName YourLastName.

Any questions, comments, or additional feedback is welcomed to the EVV Help Email at EVVHelp@health.ny.gov.

Q: Can providers and fiscal intermediaries opt out of using EVV?

A: No. Providers and fiscal intermediaries will not be able to opt out of using EVV.

Q: Will there be cost sharing or increased reimbursement rates to account for the additional costs associated with implementing EVV?

A: Under the Choice Model, providers and fiscal intermediaries self-select an EVV vendor that meets the needs of their constituents and self-fund its implementation. Providers and fiscal intermediaries with an existing EVV solution must ensure it meets federal and state requirements and configure data collection to meet NYS standards as published and periodically updated on the NYS EVV website.

Q: What level of compliance is required of providers and fiscal intermediaries for EVV?

A: All EVV services are required to have complete EVV data in order to be considered a verified visit. If NYSDOH detects steady non-compliance over time, NYSDOH reserves the right to conduct a compliance review. Depending on the results of the compliance review, NYSDOH may refer a provider agency or FI to the Office of the Medicaid Inspector General (OMIG) for audit, which may result in the review and recovery of overpayments.

Q: What services does the federal law apply to?

A: The federal law applies to Medicaid-funded Personal Care Services (PCS) and Home Health Care Services (HHCS). These services are defined in the state regulations as follows:

"Personal cares services shall mean assistance to the patient with personal hygiene, dressing, feeding, and household tasks essential to his/her health." 10 NYCRR 700.2(c) (16)

"Home health aide services shall mean health care tasks, personal hygiene services, housekeeping and other related supportive services essential to the patient’s health." 10 NYCRR 700.2(c) (15)

Q: Which NYS programs does the EVV requirement apply to?

A: The EVV requirement applies to services provided under the following NYS programs:

  • 1905(a)(24) State Plan Personal Care Benefit
    • Consumer Directed Personal Assistance (CDPA)
    • Personal Care Assistance (PCA I & II)
  • 1915(c) Home and Community Based Services waivers
    • Children´s Waiver
    • Nursing Home Transition and Diversion (NHTD) waiver
    • Traumatic Brain Injury (TBI) waiver
    • Office for People with Developmental Disabilities (OPWDD) comprehensive waiver
  • 1115 Demonstration
    • CDPA
    • PCA I & II

The 21st Century Cures Act does not require EVV of specific programs, but rather requires EVV for specific services. Regardless of the program, if services rendered are Medicaid-funded personal care service (PCS) or home health care service (HHCS) that begin or end in the home and service activities of daily living (ADL) or instrumental activities of daily living (IADL), the service is subject to EVV.

Q: Is EVV required for both FFS Medicaid and Medicaid Managed Care?

A: EVV is required for both Medicaid Fee for Service (FFS) and Medicaid Managed Care (MC).

Q: Does the EVV requirement apply to the Program of All-Inclusive Care for the Elderly (PACE) program?

A: Under federal law, the EVV requirement does not apply to PACE program services.

Q: Will there be any changes to the OMIG Verification Organization (VO) program once EVV is in place in New York State?

A: Currently, there are no planned changes to the Social Services Law that enacted the Verification Organization program under OMIG in 2014. Providers must comply with both the 21st Century Cures Act and the VO program through OMIG.

Q: Our agency does not meet the $15 million minimum of the VO program; do we still need to participate in EVV?

A: Yes. The 21st Century Cures Act is a federal law, passed by Congress in December 2016, that requires all state Medicaid programs to implement an EVV system by January 1, 2021, for personal care services (PCS) that begin or end in the home regardless of revenue. Home Health Care Services (HHCS) will take effect on January 1, 2023.

Q: Will the Unique Identifier requirement for home care workers through the Office of Medicaid Inspector General (OMIG) impact EVV?

A: No, not at this time. Currently, OMIG is developing a process for establishing a unique identifier for home care workers. Once established, stakeholders will be informed through the EVV website and Listserv.

Q: Is EVV required for in-home hospice?

A: Yes, EVV does apply to in-home hospice. EVV information must be submitted for Medicaid-funded Personal Care Services that begin or end in the home.

Q: Is the Children"s Waiver applicable to EVV?

A: Yes, EVV does apply to Medicaid-funded Personal Care Services (PCS) that begin or end in the home under the Children"s Waiver. A list of applicable rate and procedure codes are posted on the EVV website.

Q: Are Care Coordination Organization Health Homes required to use EVV?

A: Care Coordination Organization Health Homes are not service providers and therefore not subject to EVV. EVV information must be submitted for Medicaid-funded Personal Care Services (PCS) that begin or end in the home.

Q: Some Community Habilitation services are provided in the community. Is EVV still required if the services are not provided in the home?

A: Community Habilitation (CH) services are frequently provided in the community outside of the person´s home. A CH service claim would not require EVV reporting if the services being claimed are delivered entirely in the community. CH Services that are delivered entirely in the community are CH services that are not provided completely or partially in the home. Please see the EVV Applicable Billing Codes document for OPWDD CH rate codes that are impacted.

Q: Are Supported Employment Programs through OPWDD subject to EVV?

A: No, the Supported Employment Program (SEMP) and the Employment Training Program (ETP) are not subject to EVV. To confirm that the service you are currently providing is within the EVV scope, please see the EVV Applicable Billing Codes document for procedure and rate codes that are impacted.

Q: Is the signature from the consumer participating in the CDPAP or Self-Direction required to accompany EVV data when providing a Medicaid-funded service?

A: No, the signature is not required to be submitted to the NYS Aggregator.

Q: What is considered an EVV "in-home" visit and how does it differ from an EVV "Community" visit?

A: A visit is considered an EVV applicable "in-home" visit when the site of service occurs within the home, includes ADLs or IADLs, and the EVV applicable service is billed to NYS Medicaid as a claim. It is not considered an "in-home" visit if the aide is picking up or dropping off a consumer at their residence and briefly touches the home to assist that consumer in and out of the home because the site of service did not occur within the home.

Q: Are services delivered through telehealth subject to EVV?

A: At this time, EVV applicable services that occur via telehealth are not required to have data submitted to the NYS aggregator; however, NYSDOH cautions that further guidance is likely on this issue as telehealth utilization has increased during the COVID-19 pandemic and may continue as an emergent care method moving forward.

Q: What type of EVV system must be used?

A: Federal law does not require the use of one particular or uniform EVV system. However, it does require that the system can electronically verify visits conducted as part of personal care services (PCS) or home health care services (HHCS). The following must be captured:

  • type of service performed;
  • individual receiving the service;
  • date of the service;
  • location of service delivery;
  • individual providing the service; and
  • time the service begins and ends

New York State, along with guidance from the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS), determined the following technologies are compliant methods for collecting Electronic Visit Verification (EVV) data:

  • Telephony: Telephone calls can be used to capture service period and verify location. Typically captured with a landline telephone.
  • Mobile App: Apps can be downloaded and used to capture service period and verify location. This option allows the worker to record visits using a smart phone or tablet, even when no cellular, satellite, or other data services are available at the service location.
  • Fixed Object (FOB): In-home Fixed Object devices with a unique ID verify location.

Note: Under the Choice Model, NYSDOH will not endorse, approve, or recommend any specific EVV systems or provide a list of systems from which providers and fiscal intermediaries must select.

Q: Must I purchase an EVV System?

A: The Choice Model allows providers and fiscal intermediaries to self-select and self-fund their EVV system of choice or modify their current system to meet federal and state requirements.

Providers and fiscal intermediaries who have already invested in an EVV system may continue to use that system, modifying it as needed to meet the federal requirements of the Cures Act and NYS requirements.

Providers and fiscal intermediaries who do not have an EVV system have the flexibility and freedom to choose a solution that best fits the needs of the consumers they serve and their organization.

Q: Will New York State provide a list of approved systems?

A: New York State will not endorse, approve, or recommend a vendor or EVV system. Under the Choice model, providers and fiscal intermediaries have the flexibility to select a system that best meets the needs of their practice and consumers and meets the 21st Century Cures Act requirements.

Q: Will New York State certify EVV systems?

A: No. Currently, NYSDOH does not plan to certify EVV vendor systems.

Q: How do we know if our current EVV provider/component is compliant with the requirements?

A: Providers and fiscal intermediaries have the flexibility and freedom to utilize their current EVV systems or choose an EVV solution that best fits the needs of the consumers they serve and their organization, so long as it meets the requirements of the 21st Century Cures Act and is capable of submitting EVV data to eMedNY. There is currently no NYSDOH process for certifying that individual EVV solutions meet these requirements.

Providers and fiscal intermediaries must make independent decisions about what EVV systems they will purchase or continue to utilize. Providers and fiscal intermediaries should ensure that they review the 21st Century Cures Act and reference the NYSDOH EVV website for recommended considerations for selecting an EVV system.

Q: What if the consumer has no phone for the aide to use and/or the aide has no phone to capture EVV services? 

A: It is the responsibility of the provider agency or fiscal intermediary to determine how EVV data will be captured by the aide to ensure EVV compliance.

Q: Can the aide use the consumer"s cell phone to capture EVV services? 

A: It is the responsibility of the provider agency or fiscal intermediary to determine how EVV data will be captured by the aide to ensure EVV compliance.

Q: Is a Global Positioning System (GPS) mandatory for EVV?

A: No. GPS is not currently required for EVV in New York State in order to submit EVV data to the NYS Aggregator through eMedNY. If a provider agency or FI chooses to utilize a GPS system to capture EVV data, it is the responsibility of the provider agency or FI to maintain and store the GPS data points in the event of an audit for verification purposes. For more information on data submission, please review the EVV Interface Control Document.

Q: If GPS coordinates will not be collected, how will the location be submitted for visits using a mobile app?

A: GPS coordinates are not required to be submitted to the NYS Aggregator. Start and End Locations must be populated using the following valid values: "Home" or "Community." Please reference the EVV Interface Control Document for further details. Visits validated by GPS and other EVV technologies are auditable by OMIG and reviewed on a case-by-case basis due to the situational circumstances of each consumer´s location and acceptable range to be considered ´home.´

Q: When using GPS, is it required to be on during the full duration of the visit or only the start and end times?

A: New York State will only collect the start and end times of the visit.

Q: When utilizing GPS for EVV data collection, how close to a designated location will the visit need to be recorded to be considered a valid visit? What is the acceptable range?

A: It is the providers" and fiscal intermediaries" responsibility to determine that visit data collected through the GPS is collected within the means of the EVV company´s validating capabilities. It is the responsibility of the provider and fiscal intermediary to monitor GPS clock in and clock out coordinates against clients" locations on the date of service. Visits validated by GPS are auditable by OMIG and reviewed on a case-by-case basis due to the situational circumstances of each consumer´s location and acceptable range to be considered ´home.´

Q: Who should submit the EVV data to NYSDOH (Provider, MCO, EVV system)?

A: NYSDOH has selected the Choice Model to provide flexibility and enable providers to select solution options that best address the wide range of needs and preferences of New York State Medicaid consumers while preserving existing investments in EVV solutions. Providers should decide how EVV data will be submitted based on the arrangement that best fits their chosen solution.

NYSDOH has designed the data submission interface to handle a wide variety of submitters, including "third parties" or "proxies" such as Managed Care Organizations (MCO) and Verification Organizations (VO). Providers may choose to submit EVV data directly to NYSDOH. However, NYSDOH observes that many providers have chosen to work with Verification Organizations to submit a subset of the EVV data elements that most of them already collect to NYSDOH on the providers´ behalf.

Q: Are providers required to enroll with eMedNY for EVV data to be accepted? 

A: Yes, if you are not currently enrolled with eMedNY, please visit the eMedNY website to learn more about how to enroll.

Q: Our agency is National Provider Identifier (NPI) exempt and we have a Medicaid provider ID. Can we use our Medicaid provider ID, or should we get an NPI?

A: Your Medicaid ID can be used to get web portal credentials and to request an API key. Atypical providers do not require an NPI.

Q: Which data elements are required to be submitted for EVV?

A: The required elements can be found in the Interface Control Document (ICD) which has been posted to the NYSDOH EVV website. Selected systems must comply with the Federal 21st Century Cures Act requirements. Providers are responsible for reviewing the Cures Act and making sure that they select systems that comply.

Q: Will the New York State be conducting testing with submitters?

A: EVV testing and production are currently available. Testing allows EVV submitters to test connectivity with the API and submit EVV data. Validations are also enabled in the test environment, so providers are able to test various use cases. Please email  emednyapirequest@gdit.com to get started with testing. As a tester, you will be able to utilize your current eMedNY credentials to begin the process of submitting EVV data with the interface. Outlined below are the steps providers should follow:

Step 1: Enroll as a NYS Medicaid Provider and get an MMIS ID, if necessary

Step 2: Determine who will be your "submitter" (you can be your own submitter)

Step 3: If your submitter is not yet enrolled as a Medicaid Provider, have them enroll too

Step 4: Have the submitter obtain the login credentials for the eMedNY API Developer Portal from the eMedNY Provider Web Portal

Step 5: Using web portal credentials, login to https://developer.emednytest.io (available now for testing) OR https://developer.emedny.io (PROD which will be made available later), to request API keys.

Q: If we have multiple provider IDs, does each one need to be registered?

A: No, one provider ID can be used to register for a portal account and request API keys.

(Please note that Registration is a separate process from Attestation. Attestations are required for each MMIS ID or NPI that is used to bill for services subject to EVV.)

If you are a billing provider, you should use your MMIS ID to submit EVV data on behalf of the providers (i.e., Caregivers/Aides) that you represent. All of your provider IDs have to be enrolled in NYS Medicaid. However, you only need to register one for the Submitter ID.

Any one of your MMIS IDs can be used to create an account on eMedNY Provider Web Portal. The chosen MMIS ID will become your Submitter ID for your EVV data submissions and can be used to submit EVV data for the various programs in your organization. It is important to note that the Submitter ID may be different from the Provider ID that is in the Billing Provider field in the EVV payload.

For example, if your organization has MMIS ID1, MMIS ID2, and MMIS ID3, and you use MMIS ID2 to create an account on the eMedNY API Developer Portal, then MMIS ID2 will be the Submitter ID for your organization. MMIS ID2 will submit EVV data containing a Billing Provider ID which can be any one of the three MMIS IDs that your organization uses.

Q: When should EVV data be submitted to the API? For example, should data be submitted before the claim is submitted?

A: NYSDOH recommends that EVV data be submitted after the service has been rendered and before the claim is billed.

Q: When a submitter sends EVV data, will eMedNY create a claim for the submitter?

A: eMedNY will not be creating claims based on an EVV submission. The EVV data and claims data are submitted separately. The State prefers that the EVV data be sent prior to the claims data. Claims will still need to be submitted in accordance with NYSDOH policy.

Q: How would we integrate EVV into our current billing and payroll system? Would we bill in batch format directly to eMedNY via 837i transmission files?

A: Submission of EVV data to NYSDOH is done via the eMedNY EVV webservice and is separate from claims adjudication at this time. Providers should continue to bill claims via the 837i transaction.

Q; How is New York State going to identify the provider we are submitting data for and how will you match claims data from the provider"s billing software?

A: The provider is identified by their NPI or their MMIS ID in the EVV payload. This identifier will be used when the EVV data is matched with the claims data.

Q: Is EVV requiring that the Social Security number of the worker be submitted to CMS in order to bill?

A: A Caregiver ID field has been added in lieu of the servicing provider"s SSN and TaxPayer ID. Please reference the EVV Interface Control Document here for further details.

Q: When retrieving EVV data, will we be able to see which API key that record was sent from?

A: No, API Key will not be part of response. A submitter may retrieve an EVV record by performing a GET request containing the Transaction ID used to submit the EVV record.

Q: Are there any sample files (records) available?

A: Sample requests can be found in the EVV Interface Control Document located on the EVV website.

Q: Do I need to send EVV applicable manual entries to the NYS Aggregator?

A: Not currently. NYSDOH requires that providers and fiscal intermediaries maintain all EVV data documentation and write a brief justification for why a manual entry was used instead of using a compliant EVV method.

Q: Can a manual entry or paper timesheet be used to capture services when necessary?

A: All EVV services are required to have complete EVV data in order to be considered a verified visit. Manual entries should only be used when absolutely necessary. Manual entries are auditable by OMIG and NYSDOH ​and will be monitored and reviewed on a case-by-case basis due to the situational circumstances of each agency and their need to utilize manual entries as an option for capturing services. The provider agency or fiscal intermediary must retain and maintain documentation of the reason for the manual entry.

Q: As a provider, should I round my EVV data to align with the current universal billing codes rounding guidance?

A: No. The submission of EVV data is separate from your current billing practices. The EVV data submitted should be the exact time the service started and ended. Providers should continue to bill as they currently do for those services. ​NYSDOH will continuously assess EVV data needs and requirements and update the EVV stakeholder community appropriately.

Q: How should EVV data for overnight visits be submitted?

A: When submitting EVV data for overnight visits, the start date and time is required for the begin date of service, and the end date and time is required for the end date of service. For example: Start date and time: 2020-07-15 08:03:46PM. End date and time: 2020-07-16 7:16:09 AM. To learn more about data specifics, please review the Interface Control Document (ICD) on the EVV website.

Q: In the ICD, it states that there will be a 99.98% uptime excluding planned outages. How often will outages be planned and how will notice be sent to users?

A:  Planned outages will occur very infrequently. Notices will be sent through the eMedNY listserv to notify users in advance in the event of an outage.

Q: Will we be able to export the EVV data in a csv format into our current database system (MySQL)?

A: There is currently no functionality in the eMedNY EVV web service API to download EVV data.

Q: Do you expect that in the future EVV data will be submitted on the 837?

A: NYSDOH will continue to evaluate EVV data needs. As part of this evaluation, NYSDOH will consider modifying New York State requirements based on the success of the initial implementation. The option for EVV data to be submitted on the 837 will be one of the options considered.

Q: Where can I find more information on Electronic Visit Verification (EVV) from the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS)?

A: Information released by CMS related to EVV can be found here.

Q: How do I contact the State regarding EVV if I have any questions or concerns?

A: You may contact New York State with any questions or comments at EVVHelp@health.ny.gov.

Q: Who do I contact regarding testing, the API Developer Portal, or other technical issues?

A: Please contact eMedNY Tier 2 Operations at emednyproviderservices@gdit.com or emednyapirequest@gdit.com.

Q: Who do I contact about eMedNY Enrollment or the EVV Attestation Portal?

A: Please contact the eMedNY Call Center at (800) 343-9000.

Q: How do I sign up for the EVV Listserv to ensure I am receiving necessary updates?

A: To sign up for the EVV Listserv, email listserv@listserv.health.state.ny.us with the following in the body of your email: SUBSCRIBE EVV-L YourFirstName YourLastName.


Disclaimer
This document serves as an informational reference for stakeholders participating in the NY Medicaid EVV Program. Although reasonable effort has been made to assure the accuracy of the information within these pages at the time of posting, it is the responsibility of each provider and fiscal intermediary to comply with the current policies and requirements for the program.